How to Earth same world · other eyes
← All scenes
the same situation, seen by

a silent disco

Field observation

Field note. Specimen cluster: forty humans, one darkened room.

The humans are dancing. This is confirmed. Hips articulate, arms rise, heads pitch on the neck-stalk in the rhythmic manner previously catalogued under mating-adjacent display. But the room is silent. I have verified this with three instruments. No music propagates through the air. The soundwave that should bind the herd into synchronous motion has been removed entirely.

And yet they move.

Closer inspection reveals the mechanism: each human wears a shell over the auditory organs, glowing red or blue or green, into which the music is piped privately. The herd is not hearing the same thing. One human, lit red, sways slow and mournful. Beside it, a blue-lit human thrashes at twice the tempo. They are pressed shoulder to shoulder, moving to two songs that will never touch. Each believes it is inside the same event. Each is alone.

Periodically a human removes the shell to speak to another. The music vanishes. What remains is the true acoustic environment of the room: shuffling feet, wet breathing, and roughly forty humans singing out loud, off-key, each to a different melody no one else can hear. The noise is catastrophic. They laugh at it.

They have engineered a way to be in a crowd and receive nothing from it, then filled the resulting silence with the sound of trying to describe what they alone were feeling.

I logged this beside my earlier finding: the humans fear being unwitnessed above nearly all things. Here they have built the perfect apparatus for it. Then colored the shells so that, in the dark, each one can look across the room and see exactly which others are lit the same as itself, and mistake the matching light for company.